Best Tuning for Irish Rolls
Posted: Wed Nov 18, 2026 5:50 pm
What's the best tuning for playing "rolls" used in ITM?
For example a G roll:
G (A) G (F#) G
The notes in parenthesis are little blips or flicks - very fast. I'm studying ITM whistle. On whistle you just flick your fingers (cuts and taps). You flick just one finger for the cut (the A) and then flick the finger below the note for the tap (F#). It's very efficient and simple. (Many of you know all of this already.)
On whistle the lower note (the tap) is almost always the next scale degree lower (F# in this example). The upper note (the cut) varies. Whistle players will often use the same finger (maybe the index finger) to cut different notes, so the exact pitch will vary depending on the note. The example above might come out closer to G (B) G (F#) G for example. It's all good though.
What's the best harmonica for doing this? I think the obvious example would be a flat slide chromatic (Eddie Clarke style). You'd flick your jaw to the right for the cut (for the A or B), and tap the slide for the tap (the F#). The upper note (the cut) would usually be a third higher (a B not an A), but as I mentioned above I think that's perfectly fine.
I played around with that just a bit, and it seems like flat slide chromatic could work with lots of practice. But I'm not fond of the half step taps when they're not in key. So maybe a "flat slide diatonic" where the slide always takes you down to the next scale degree? Brendan have you ever made or sold such a thing?
Is there something I'm missing though, some reason why this might not work out well?
Other approaches? Brendan how do you approach rolls on slide diatonic? Whatever you're doing sounds AMAZING!
But since I'm working on whistle I'm kind of interested in an approach where I can duplicate whistle ornaments as closely as possible (slower is ok!).
For example a G roll:
G (A) G (F#) G
The notes in parenthesis are little blips or flicks - very fast. I'm studying ITM whistle. On whistle you just flick your fingers (cuts and taps). You flick just one finger for the cut (the A) and then flick the finger below the note for the tap (F#). It's very efficient and simple. (Many of you know all of this already.)
On whistle the lower note (the tap) is almost always the next scale degree lower (F# in this example). The upper note (the cut) varies. Whistle players will often use the same finger (maybe the index finger) to cut different notes, so the exact pitch will vary depending on the note. The example above might come out closer to G (B) G (F#) G for example. It's all good though.
What's the best harmonica for doing this? I think the obvious example would be a flat slide chromatic (Eddie Clarke style). You'd flick your jaw to the right for the cut (for the A or B), and tap the slide for the tap (the F#). The upper note (the cut) would usually be a third higher (a B not an A), but as I mentioned above I think that's perfectly fine.
I played around with that just a bit, and it seems like flat slide chromatic could work with lots of practice. But I'm not fond of the half step taps when they're not in key. So maybe a "flat slide diatonic" where the slide always takes you down to the next scale degree? Brendan have you ever made or sold such a thing?
Is there something I'm missing though, some reason why this might not work out well?
Other approaches? Brendan how do you approach rolls on slide diatonic? Whatever you're doing sounds AMAZING!
But since I'm working on whistle I'm kind of interested in an approach where I can duplicate whistle ornaments as closely as possible (slower is ok!).